"Bayou Bill" Scifres
Dedicated to the conservation and enjoyment of Indiana's natural resources
About Bayou Bill
Recent Rambles
DNR Doings
Wild Recipes
Favored Hoosier Waters for Crappies
Copyright © 2002 by Bill Scifres

If  you haven't seen them already, you will be seeing them soon--well-bundled anglers fishing along causeways and man-made obstructions in lakes of the state. 

They are fishing for crappies (pronounced croppies). Albeit slow, the late-winter, early-spring crappie fishing cannot be denied by those who seek and eat these tasty members of the sunfish family. 

While both white and black crappies will be found in many standing waters and sluggish streams and rivers of the state, some waters are considered better than others. 

To learn more about these favored waters, we went to the fisheries biologists of the Division of Fish and Wildlife's eight fisheries management districts. Here is what the fisheries biologists, who are in constant touch with the waters of their respective districts, say: 

Bob Robertson--(District 1, 16 northwestern counties): Bass Lake, Starke County, has lots of crappies and they range up to 10-12 inches. Clear Lake, LaPorte County is another good bet, and Worster Lake in Potato Creek State Park (St. Joseph County), Manitou Lake at Rochester (Fulton County), and Lake Freeman, at Monticello (White and Carroll counties) offer good fishing. 

Neil Ledet--(District 2, Elkhart, Lagrange and Steuben counties on the Michigan state line): Lake James at Pokagon State Park in Steuben County probably best in the district, but the south end of Big Turkey on the Steuben-Lagrange county line is very good. There are a lot of crappies in the 9-10 inch class in these lakes and some run larger. 

Jed Pearson--(District 3, Allen, Dekalb, Noble counties, and the upper part of Kosciusko County): The West Lake Chain (more specifically Waldron, Jones, Tamarack, and Steinbarger lakes, all in Noble County), give up a lot of crappies in the 9-10 inch class, but the channels on the larger lakes of the district also offer good fishing  in late April and early May. 

Ed Braun--(District 4, 14 northeastern counties and the lower part of  Kosciusko County):  Salamonie Reservoir, (Wabash and Huntington counties) and Mississinewa Reservoir (Miami and Wabash counties) Braun favors Salamonie slightly because the water level probably will remain low at Mississinewa Reservoir as repair work on the dam continues. The low-water level will make it difficult to fish Mississinewa, but the river channel could offer good fishing for crappies. 

Doug Keller--(District 5,  20 counties across the central part of the state): Raccoon Reservoir and Cataract Lake probably are best bets. A fish survey at Raccoon last year showed half of the fish taken were crappies and while there are a lot of small fish, they run up to 13-16 inches, averaging 8 ½ (eight and one-half) inches. Standing timber not easy to find on these lakes, but any natural or man-made structure could hold crappies. Eagle Creek and Brookville reservoirs also offer good fishing for smaller crappies. 

Brian Schoenung--(District 6,  10 southwestern counties, made up largely of strip-mined pits): Dogwood Lake at Glendale State Fish and Wildlife Area), and West Boggs Creek Lake (at West Boggs Park on the Daviess/Martin county line north of Loogootee): Crappies at Dogwood and West Boggs average about ½ (one-half) pound, but they run much larger. Schoenung also likes Sullivan Lake (at the town of Sullivan in the county of the same name) for crappies, adding that this lake also has a good saugeye population (a cross between walleye and sauger). 

Dan Carnahan--(District 7,  10 southwestern counties, much of which is in the strip-mined area): Carnahan likes Hovey Lake (at Hovey Lake State Fish and Wildlife Area) best, but points out that anglers there can find the crappie fishing tough until some knowledge of the lake and the fish is gained. The lake holds a lot of fish in the10-12-inch class. Best place to start is shoreline around the boat ramp. 

Larry Lehman--(District 8,  15 southeastern counties, including the embayments of  streams above the Markland Dam, Versailles Lake (in Versailles State Park), and Hardy Lake (east of Austin in Scott County):  Versailles is a tough place to fish for crappies, Lehman says, but fishing the south banks is a good bet. At Hardy, Cedar Cove is a good bet, especially around standing timber. The Bryant's Creek embayment near Markland Dam offers good crappie water, but any of the small coves and creek channels along the Indiana shoreline of the Ohio River offer crappie potential. 

However, the district biologists emphasize that crappies are not as widespread  in Hoosier water as other members of the sunfish family, especially bluegills and bass. In many cases if a body of water is not fed by a stream, or has not been stocked with crappies at some time in the past, they probably will not be present. Still crappies will be found in many waters not known for crappie fishing. 


All columns are copyrighted by Bill Scifres and may not be reproduced in any form without prior permission from the author.  For reproduction permission and media usage fees, contact: Bill Scifres, 6420 East 116th Street, Fishers, IN 46038, E-mail: billscifres@aol.com

 Return to beginning of document
Return to Bayou Bill's Home Page